Geologists debunk soil impact on wine

There is no such 'taste of the soil,' according to scientists at Portland geological conference

PORTLAND — Geologists say wine critics may be stretching things a bit when they talk about the soil giving a vintage a distinct flavor.

Wine critics often use the French phrase, "gout de terroir," which means "taste of the soil."

But scientists who met in Portland this week for the annual Geological Society of America conference say much of that taste may be imagined.

The geologists say wines may vary in levels of dissolved minerals, but those variations aren't related to the levels in vineyard soil.

And they say the concentration of minerals in wine is below the threshold of human taste and smell.

"I am not saying that chemistry and geology have no effect on the wine. It may have effects that we don't understand," said geologist Alex Maltman.

"But whatever 'minerality' in wine is, it is not the taste of vineyard minerals," he said.

Debunking mistaken notions about terroir — how landforms, soils, climate and other local conditions define the character of wine — was one goal of the scientists during the meeting.

"When people talk about terroir, it all sounds very fancy and all very marvelous and it makes it sound like we really know something. But I guarantee you, we know very little," said Jonathan Swinchatt, a geologist and consultant to several high-end California vineyards.

In Oregon's Rogue Valley, climatologist Greg Jones of Southern Oregon University combined information from soil surveys, climate records, zoning and other sources to map areas most likely to produce excellent wine grapes.

Jones found that more than half of existing vineyards are planted on land that is only marginally suitable for growing grapes. Nearly a third of the planted acreage is mismatched to climate: Cool-climate grapes such as pinot noir are growing where it's too warm, and varieties requiring more heat are growing where it's too cold.

Scott Burns, a geology professor at Portland State University who helped organize the session, conducted a test that did little to settle the question. He offered fellow scientists wines made in the same style from the same pinot noir clones on two different soils: volcanic jory versus marine-sediment Willakenzie soil.

In a show of hands for a taste test, geologists picked the Willakenzie 40 to 15. But Burns, who has repeated the test with other audiences, said the running score is close to 50-50.

"Nobody is right," Burns said. "It goes back and forth."

Reader Reaction
We reserve the right to remove any content at any time from this Community, including without limitation if it violates the Community Rules. We ask that you report content that you in good faith believe violates the above rules by clicking the Flag link next to the offending comment or fill out this form. New comments are only accepted for two weeks from the date of publication.